The Rangers played utility guy Josh Smith in center field last night, something that Shawn McFarland of The Dallas Morning News spoke to manager Bruce Bochy about. Smith had played a bit of center field in the minors but this was his first appearance there in the big leagues.
The decision speaks to a couple of things, one of which is just that the club wanted to get Smith in there somewhere. “He’s swinging the bat so well,” Bochy said. “I’ve got to find a place for him in the lineup.” Smith currently sports a monster line of .367/.456/.571 on the season. He won’t be able to keep a .485 batting average on balls in play going forever but he’s drawing walks at a 14% clip and his hard hit rate on pace to jump for a third straight year.
Given that performance, it’s understandable that Bochy wants to ride the hot hand, but Smith’s regular spots are taken. The Rangers have Jake Burger, Marcus Semien, Corey Seager and Josh Jung around the infield. Joc Pederson is the designated hitter while Wyatt Langford and Adolis García are in the outfield corners. Not everyone in that group is performing well but the struggling ones are established big league bats and should bounce back.
Center field is a bit more open, however. Leody Taveras has seen most of the playing time there in recent seasons but with diminishing returns. He managed to hit .266/.312/.421 for a league average 100 wRC+ in 2023. When combined with his speed and defense, that made him a useful player. But he dropped down to a .229/.289/.352 line and 82 wRC+ last year. It’s even worse so far in 2025, as he currently sports a dismal .197/.210/.246 line. He is striking out at a 27.4% pace so far and only drawing walks 1.6% of the time.
Time will tell if it’s a brief experiment or if Smith says in there longer, which will presumably depend on many factors. An injury for anyone else on the diamond might lead to Smith being moved elsewhere. Dustin Harris and Kevin Pillar have also been performing well in part-time roles. If Smith’s results taper off or Taveras improves, perhaps the calculus will change.
There’s also the Evan Carter factor. He once seemed like a potential long-term solution in center, as he came up late in 2023 and hit the ground running, playing a key role in the club’s title run that year. But he was injured for most of last year and the Rangers optioned him to Triple-A Round Rock to start this year, where he’s currently hitting .167/.352/.262.
General manager Ross Fenstermaker tells McFarland that the club is “pretty encouraged” by Carter’s progress as he works on managing his autoimmune back issue and making a swing adjustment. “We’re confident that he’s going to find his footing here and get going,” Fenstermaker said. “When that time comes that he’s the best option to help this club, he’ll be up here.”
Carter may be a factor down the line but his Triple-A numbers don’t suggest he’s likely to be called upon soon. That situation and the recent struggles of Taveras have opened a spot for Smith, which has expanded his versatility. He has now played every position on the diamond outside of the battery. His glovework in the outfield corners has been around league average thus far, but center field will be a bit more of a test for him defensively.
Photo courtesy of Ed Szczepanski, Imagn Images